Skip to main content
  • Outlaw Oyster logo top - Homepage
    Outlaw Oyster logo scroll - Homepage
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Yappy Hour
  • Join The Waitlist
    • Join the waitlist at theWauwatosa location
    • Join the waitlist at theMilwaukee location
  • Parties
  • Jobs
    Outlaw Oyster logo top - HomepageOutlaw Oyster logo scroll - Homepage
      • Menu
      • Drinks
      • Yappy Hour
      • Join The Waitlist
        • Join the waitlist at theWauwatosa location
        • Join the waitlist at theMilwaukee location
      • Parties
      • Jobs

      Our Menu

      • Menu
      • Yappy Hour Menu

      *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, eggs or unpasteurized milk may increase your risk of foodborne illness

      Oysters on The Half Shell*

      Check our oyster menu for current offerings • Hot Sauce | 2 Versions Migonette | Cocktail Sauce • Order minimum of 3 oysters • Shooter - House Bloody Mix & Veggie Vodka

      Outlaw Special

      1/2 dozen chefs choice oysters, Outlaw beer

      Daily Dozen

      Dozen chefs choice oysters, daily spritz

      For the Table

      Shrimp Cocktail

      1/2 LB Shrimp, House Cocktail Sauce

      Pimento Cheese Ball

      Pimento Cheese Ball, Walnuts, Chives, Ritz Crackers

      Smoked Fish Plate

      Choice of Cajun Salmon or Smoked Trout, Pimento cheese, Green Goddess, Pickled Veg, Crackers

      Tinned & Toasted

      Choice of Tinned Fish, Lemon Creme, Gherkins, Pimento Cheese, Tiny Toasts, Micro Radish

      Hot Smoked Salmon Dip

      Cajun Smoked Salmon, Smoked Cheddar, Cream Cheese, Capers, Ritz Crackers

      Caesar Fries

      Crispy Fries in Caesar, Piles of Parm, Flaky Salt, Chives, Lemon

      Octopus Aguachile Negro

      Octopus, Aguachile Negro, Cilantro, Cucumber, Pickled Red Onion, Chili Crisp

      Lobster Claw Basket

      1/2 LB Lobster Claws, Butter

      Sandwiches

      All Sandwiches Come With Fries | Upgrade to Caesar Fries +$4 or House Slaw +$2

      Connecticut Lobster Roll Sliders

      Melted Butter, Chives, Butter Rolls

      XL Lobster Roll

      Melted Butter, Chives, Toasted Roll Heaped w/ the Good Stuff

      Pickled Veg Sandwich

      Pickled Peppers, Pickled Red Onion, Pickled Mustard Seed, Gherkins, Carrots, Micro Radish, Dill, Soft Egg, Pimento Cheese, Ciabatta Roll

      Cajun Salmon & Pimento Cheese Melt

      Cajun Smoked Salmon, Heirloom Tomato, Pimento Cheese, Pickled Pepper, Texas Toast

      Green Goddess Shrimp Roll

      Shrimp, Cucumber, Red Onion, Lemon, Shrettuce, Green Goddess Dressing, Toasted Roll

      Smoked Trout Banh Mi

      Smoked Trout, Crispy Bacon, Carrots, Cucumber, Jalapeno, Cilantro, Chile Crisp Mayo, Ciabatta Roll

      Octodog

      Octopus Tentacle, Chile Crisp Mayo, Pickled Red Onion, Salmon Roe, Cucumber, Barnacle Kelp Furikake, Toasted Roll

      Crafty Classic

      Double Oklahoma Smash Patty, American, Pickles, Special Sauce | Add Buttered Lobster

      Desserts

      Strawberry Biscuits Shortcake

      Two Crumbly Buttermilk Biscuits Topped with Strawberry Compote & Whipped Cream

      Maple Whip Funnel Fries

      Crispy Funnel Cake Fries Dusted in Cinnamon Sugar served with a Salted Maple Whip

      Classic Cheesecake

      Classic Creamy New York Cheesecake

      Strawberry Cheesecake

      Classic New York Cheesecake Topped with House Strawberry Compote

      Old Fashioned Carrot Cake

      Moist Spiced Carrot Cake with Pineapple, Coconut, Almonds, Walnuts, Pecans & Cream Cheese Frosting

      For the curious and the kind rebels — Yappy Hour is where flavors surprise, friends gather, and the night begins (or refuses to end). | *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, eggs, or unpasteurized milk may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

      Golden Hour Yappy Hour

      Catch the glow of Golden Hour with us! Enjoy our Yappy Hour specials all day on Wednesdays and from 4–5 PM Thursday–Sunday — the perfect start before the night shines. | *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, eggs, or unpasteurized milk may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

      Oysters*

      $2.00
      $3.00
      Each Rotating Daily

      Cajun Salmon + Cheese & Crackers

      $10.00

      Smoked Whitefish + Cheese & Crackers

      $10.00

      Smoked Trout + Cheese & Crackers

      $12.00

      Drink

      Outlaw Beer

      $3.00

      Tiny Tinis

      $3.00
      Outlaw or Espresso

      Off Glass Pours

      $2.00

      Oyster Shooters

      $4.00

      Still Yappin'

      The night doesn’t end when the glow fades — we’re Still Yappin’! Thursday–Saturday from 8:30–10 PM, enjoy all your Golden Hour Yappy Hour favorites plus even more late-night bites and sips to keep the good times rolling. | *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, eggs, or unpasteurized milk may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

      Lobster Claws + Hot Butter

      $15.00

      Smoked Whitefish Dip

      $8.00

      Shrimp Cocktail

      $8.00

      Tinned Fish, Crackers, & Lemon Crème

      $9.00

      Octopus Aguachile

      $9.00

      Caesar Fries

      $6.00

      Let's Get It All

      The Full Spread - $50 | One of each Night Bite. For the table, for the memory.

      Bottles for the Table

      $30 Bottle of Bubbles OR $30 Bottle of Muscadet
      • Reserve
      • Parties
      • Jobs